Karimova v. NorDx

Insurance Company


Date Decided

January 16, 2018

Panel Members

Glen Goodnough

Sue Jerome

Mike Stovall


Res Judicata


Carpal Tunnel

File Size

167 KB


Summary from the Troubh Heisler Attorneys

Ms. Karimova claimed a 2006 carpal tunnel injury, which she had failed to raise in a previous round of litigation involving an unsuccessful mediation of her other claimed dates of injury. NorDx argued that, because she could have raised that date of injury in the prior mediation, her failure to do so then barred her claim now under the principles of res judicata. Judge Collier disagreed with NorDx and granted Ms. Karimova’s petition. NorDx appealed.

The Appellate Division panel held that res judicata “does not extend so far as to necessarily bar a claim” that the employee could have asserted in a previous round of litigation, and that res judicata applies only after the WCB renders a final adjudication. Although mediation agreements are equivalent to a final adjudication, “records of unresolved mediations that merely recite issues in dispute do not have the same res judicata effect.”

Page |